Criticism
Ongoing coverage on Criticism.
Latest coverage
The Sunday Papers
This article discusses various essays and critical pieces, touching on interactive fiction tools like Twine, the complexities of identity and geopolitics, film analysis of "Once Upon a Time in the Middle East," the nature of horror in media, transgender rights, and the societal and environmental impacts of generative AI.
What We Learned About Review Scores After 12 Years of Xbox Reviews
This analysis discusses the evolution and meaning of video game review scores over 12 years of Xbox reviews, highlighting that consistency and transparency in criteria are more important than the score itself. It emphasizes that readers build trust through a publication's track record and clear evaluation frameworks, especially in an era where professional criticism competes with numerous online opinions.
Jeff Kaplan Tells Gamers to ‘Shut Up’ About Games They Won’t Play
Former Overwatch director Jeff Kaplan has sparked controversy by telling gamers to "shut up" about games they won't play, arguing that developers receive excessive criticism from non-players. While some developers and gamers support his stance against bad-faith feedback, others criticize his unprofessional and dismissive approach, fearing it could stifle important conversations about game design and accessibility.
